Downtown Ice Cream Shop Reopens With New Owners And A New Name

It’s the same great taste and funky décor at Pawcatuck’s Downtown Creamery but now it’s called Mel’s Downtown Creamery. Under new ownership the ice cream holds its grand opening and ribbon cutting today.


Eight scoops of ice cream, seven toppings, a banana, a warm brownie, whip cream and cherries. Called the Big Kahuna, the ice cream sundae serves four and is one of the most popular items on the menu at in Pawcatuck.

It’s also a familiar item. Because while Mel’s Downtown Creamery and owners Melanie and Dennis Goggin are new, the Big Kahuna is old. It was part of the menu when Mel’s was simply Downtown Creamery.

“When people heard we took over the place they begged us to keep the Big Kahuna,” Melanie said.

The Westerly couple brought the ice cream shop with the 1950s sweet shop feel earlier this year, reopening the store under the name Mel’s Downtown Creamery. Today, they will hold the shop’s official .

“Everything finally fell into place,” Melanie said. “It’s a cute place and ready to rock n’ roll."

For the past eight years while Melanie managed an ice cream shop in Cranston, R.I., her family kept pushing her to open up her own place.

“It was do 'I jump or not jump,'” Melanie said with laugh.

Her younger sister was friends with the daughter of Downtown Creamery’s owners and when they were looking to sell Melanie and her husband were ready to take the chance.

They opened the store in March. Melanie working 12 hour plus days and Dennis helping out after finishing his regular workday, as an active duty guardsman in the Connecticut Air National Guard.

They should be exhausted, but Melanie is all smiles full of excitement saying it’s different when you’re working for yourself.

“I love it,” Melanie said. “After three weeks it seems like home. I get to implement my ideas.”

One of those ideas is chocolate dipped frozen cheesecake, which has quickly become another menu favorite. Others include birthday parties and maybe soon a man vs. food contest featuring the Big Kahuna.

Already the shop takes a picture of everyone who orders the Big Kahuna and puts it on the Big Kahuna board. It is one of the things that gives the shop its community feel and Melanie is already quick to point out that they wouldn’t be where they are without locals rooting for them.

“The support from friends and family has been really touching,” Melanie said. “And Dennis is being very supportive. He has a lot of fun, he enjoys talking to people and he makes the best shaved ice, as good as you would get in Hawaii.”

The couple, both in their early 30s, married last June and have big plans for themselves, the store and the community. Melanie said they want to stay open year-round and will hire more people, as they get busier. And someday Melanie said they hope to raise a family here, although for now Melanie tells her mother to think of the store as her grandbaby.

“We’re not going anywhere,” Melanie said.

Mel’s Downtown Creamery, 37 W Broad St., Pawcatuck, Conn., holds their Grand Opening and Ribbon Cutting Tuesday, April 17 from 11 a.m. to 1 p.m. Find them on Facebook at http://facebook.com/MelsDowntownCreamery and on Twitter at http://twitter.com/MelsDTCreamery.

Elissa Bass April 17, 2012 at 11:25 AM
We have loved Downtown Creamery since it opened - and you can find our picture on the Big Kahuna wall of fame - and I am glad to see that the new owners plan to keep the same welcoming atmosphere and great treats! Bring on summer!
Michael Goldstein April 17, 2012 at 12:23 PM
Mel is a gem of a person and is already giving back to the community. The treats are delicious...and they have low fat yougurt! See you there!
Joanna Gradilone April 17, 2012 at 12:57 PM
Great place. good selection of ice cream.
Edward Haberek April 17, 2012 at 04:07 PM
Great place, looking forward to attending the Ribbon Cutting this morning!
Janice Meagher April 18, 2012 at 02:40 PM
All the best!


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »